
Alberta Surgical Initiative – Reduction in Clinical Variation
Surgery (General & Specialty)
2021-02-28 – 2024-12-30
Approximately 70,000 people in Alberta were waiting for surgery at the time of the AHS Review in 2019, and 50% were considered waiting longer than clinically appropriate. The PLP team, led by PLP Medical Director Dr. Katrina Nicholson, in collaboration with AHS ASI (led by Dr. Stewart Hamilton) and AHS IHOT (led by Dr. Donald Dick), are focusing on reduction of clinical variation of 17 procedures identified by AHS ASI executive team in this multi-year
initiative. The aim is to improve the provision of surgery within our province, by reducing clinical variation to promote equity and timely access to appropriate procedures using the latest evidence and guidelines.
This project facilitates leadership from the specific specialties to generate effective change strategies within each of the identified surgeries. PLP will use its expertise in peer-to-peer driven change, HCD, and implementation science to support the ASI. The focus in 2024-25 was on three surgical procedures: tonsillectomy, prostate resection, and ureteral calculi.
PLP completed work with three working groups in 2024-25. See the summaries listed below for more information about each procedure area. PLP is not anticipating new work with the Reduction in Clinical Variation (RCV) program, although additional procedures may be considered depending on the priorities of the ASI.
PLP's engagement with the RCV team and procedure working groups produced data-informed recommendations for the ASI. For each working group, PLP contributed to the review and clinical context of procedure data, facilitated the identification of clinical variation, and supported the development of recommendations with clinicians. The PLP team brought skills in data visualization and interpretation, as well as facilitation of co-creation session(s) to the collaboration with the RCV program. The high quality of the data presented sparked valuable discussions with clinicians.
Tonsillectomy
A working group of pediatric otolaryngology specialists and PLP reviewed initial data and measures to comprehend the observed variation. To aid in this effort, PLP provided its expertise in data visualization.
In conjunction with the ASI, PLP designed and facilitated three working group meetings in 2023. These collaborative efforts are aimed at understanding and reducing clinical variation in tonsillectomy procedures, ensuring that patients receive consistent and equitable care.
In 2024-25, a final summary of recommendations was sent to ASI executive leadership for next steps. PLP's engagement with this working group is completed.
Prostate Resection
We established a working group of urologists from both the Calgary and Edmonton Zones to initiate data review and explore additional data points and measures to understand the observed variation. PLP played an instrumental role in designing and facilitating the working group meetings in collaboration with the RCV program team and Dr. Stewart Hamilton.
In 2024-25, PLP, and the RCV team led by Dr. Hamilton delivered two co-creation sessions that looked at the economic analysis of prostate resection, the opportunities for optimization of utilization of day surgery unit for this procedure, as well as access to virtual care to reduce recurrent ED visits. The working group data refinement process resulted in a recommendation to explore development of a standardized provincial treatment pathway. This work has been taken on by the clinical subject matter experts in the group. PLP's engagement with this working group is completed.
Management of Retained Ureteral Calculi
A working group was established with urologists from both the Calgary and Edmonton Zones to initiate data review and explore additional data points and measures to understand observed variation in this procedure. PLP was involved in designing and facilitating three working group meetings in collaboration with the RCV program team and Dr. Stewart Hamilton.
In 2024-25, PLP focused on exploring the reasons for variation through extensive data review and additional discovery work. The working group indicated an interest in involvement of other zones, to understand the approach to management of retained ureteral calculi in rural zones. In addition, PLP completed work to optimise the care pathway documents for Calgary Zone. A final set of recommendations was presented to ASI executive leadership. PLP's engagement with this Working group is completed.
PLP's multi-year collaboration with ASI and RCV program brought together surgical teams from across the province to explore practice variation in six key procedures. Using a HCD approach, PLP facilitated 14 interactive workshops that transformed high-level administrative data into meaningful insights through tailored visualizations, relevant comparators, and collaborative tools. These sessions enabled clinicians to identify drivers of variation---including system-level factors such as access, equipment, and perioperative supports---and to share ideas for aligning care across sites. The process not only surfaced opportunities for standardization and advocacy but also highlighted the value of ongoing data collection to support equity and evidence-based surgical care. While the project has now concluded, the clinician-informed recommendations and strengthened provincial connections continue to inform ASI's efforts to improve surgical quality and access.